On April 18, 2026, the classroom moved to Roosevelt Square in downtown São Paulo. In front of the Patrícia Galvão Municipal Early Childhood Education School, the Emei Pagu, families and educators organized a public class to protest the use of images from the school in the documentary "Pedagogy of Abandonment ," produced by the company Brasil Paralelo. The filming had been authorized by the municipal administration. According to the protesters, however, the school community knew that filming would take place, but had not been informed about the political orientation of the production or how the images would be used.
Released two days later, the documentary questions the conceptions that guide early childhood education in Brazil and criticizes what it presents as the excessive centrality of the State and daycare centers in children's development. In its publicity, Brasil Paralelo states that "families have increasingly less authority over their children's education" and informs that the film is part of a series of productions about education in the country.

The conflict surrounding the Pagu Early Childhood Education Center (Emei Pagu) has brought to light a debate that extends beyond the school environment. Who can define the educational needs of a community? Can an action directed at children, young people, or adults from working-class backgrounds be called popular education? Does the fact that it takes place in an association, a cultural center, or a social organization make it community-based or non-formal? And what happens when conservative groups begin to offer political training, operate in peripheral territories, and use words like participation , autonomy , protagonism , and transformation?
According to Carolina de Roig Catini, a professor in the Department of Social Sciences in Education at the Faculty of Education of the State University of Campinas (FE-Unicamp), answering these questions requires looking beyond the name adopted by each initiative. It is necessary to observe who conceives the action, who finances it, how it relates to the State, who decides its content, and what purposes guide the educational process.
“Often, 'non-formal education' becomes an academic term for any practice carried out outside of school,” says the researcher. This spatial definition, however, encompasses very different experiences: a workshop in a museum, a social assistance project, a self-managed preparatory course, the training of party activists, an activity of a corporate foundation, and an action organized by a popular movement can all occur outside the regular education system without sharing the same pedagogical or political project.
More than just an extracurricular activity
Non-formal education , social education , community education , and popular education are expressions with fluid boundaries, used in distinct ways by researchers and the organizations themselves. As an initial approach, non-formal education encompasses intentional educational processes developed outside or on the margins of the school system, in spaces such as museums, associations, non-governmental organizations, cultural projects, and social movements. Social education usually designates pedagogical actions linked to guaranteeing rights and working with groups subjected to different forms of exclusion. Community education, on the other hand, highlights the connection with a territory and with the organization of the collective life of a community.
The same experience can therefore be social, community-based, and non-formal at the same time. None of these classifications, by itself, determines its political orientation. Working in a marginalized area or serving people in vulnerable situations does not automatically transform an initiative into popular education.
In the article "Popular Education as a Collective Practice of Insurgency and Emancipation ," Catini and researcher Ian Gabriel Couto Schlindwein show that the very expression "popular education" is historically polysemous. It has served to designate both the expansion of education to the entire population and projects of adaptation and control of the working classes. The authors use "Popular Education," with capital letters, to highlight a political and pedagogical tradition established in Latin America: one in which exploited groups cease to be merely recipients of an action and become subjects of knowledge production, collective organization, and social transformation.
It is this political direction, and not a fixed set of techniques, that distinguishes Popular Education. It can be present in a social movement, a neighborhood association, or even within a school. Conversely, an activity carried out in a community can keep the participants in the position of beneficiary public, while external funders and leaders predefine the problem, the content, and the solution.

The debate is far from over. In a review of articles published between 2013 and 2023, released in 2026 in the journal Teias , Lucas Andrade Ananias and Nara Vieira Ramos identified a great diversity of contexts associated with non-formal education. The works analyzed frequently attribute participatory, emancipatory, and socio-political characteristics to these experiences. For Catini, this potential exists, but the analysis of isolated practices is not enough to reveal the predominant form of the field.
“To understand what is hegemonic, we have to see who the agents are, who produces it, who pays for it, and what the relationship is with the State and with formal education,” he says. A popular preparatory course, for example, can reproduce classes and content from the school because it prepares students for the university entrance exam. At the same time, it can organize its work through self-management, hold assemblies, and recognize itself as part of a popular education movement. The place where it occurs is only one dimension of the experience.
From popular mobilization to non-formal education.
Catini's research begins with the campaigns and movements that, in the early 1960s, articulated literacy, culture, and political participation. Experiences such as the Basic Education Movement, the Popular Culture Centers, and the Basic Education Movement brought together students, artists, educators, rural workers, church sectors, and university members. Paulo Freire became the best-known figure in this process, but he was far from acting alone.
Instead of treating the poor population as mere recipients of knowledge developed elsewhere, these experiences stemmed from their own language, their work, and the conflicts experienced in each territory. Learning to read was related to interpreting the world and participating in political life. During that period, literacy also had a direct consequence on a type of political participation: people who could not read and write were excluded from voting.


The 1964 coup violently interrupted this movement. Programs were discontinued; materials were seized; and educators were persecuted or exiled. It was Carlos Rodrigues Brandão who first argued that non-formal education was created during the Brazilian dictatorship as a method of domesticating popular education by the far right. Based on Brandão's proposal in the text " Alternative Education in Authoritarian Society ," from 1984, Catini continued research into the origins of non-formal education in Brazil. Part of this research is published in the text " Non-Formal Education: History and Critique of a Social Form ."
Several researchers in non-formal education identify the beginning of the use of the term in the context of a conference convened by UNESCO and USAID, held in the USA in 1967, through which the American researcher Philip Coombs systematized the diagnosis of a "world education crisis," analyzing that the amount of state resources spent on formal education was not directly reflected in the production of wealth and the gross domestic product (GDP) of each country. Among the responses to solve the crisis was the incorporation into national educational planning of practices developed outside of school. Non-formal education was presented as a flexible and less expensive alternative, especially for peripheral nations.
Based on the assumptions of Human Capital Theory and the practices of "permanent counter-revolution," multilateral organizations employed the term "non-formal education" to establish forms of control over educational practices linked to social movements fighting for emancipation. In the early 1970s, during the Brazilian military dictatorship, the Brazilian Literacy Movement, Mobral, was created. According to Catini, the new program responded to the social demand for literacy and incorporated elements developed in previous experiences, such as words related to work and collective life, but gave them a different purpose.
“The right has learned to use our terms, our words, and to change their meaning,” the researcher summarizes. Instead of political organization and the construction of popular power, concepts such as work, participation, and community have become linked to productivity, efficiency, and the adaptation of individuals to the existing order.
Mobral did not achieve its goal of eradicating illiteracy. However, according to Catini, it was successful in creating a lasting institutional framework. The program brought together government, businesses, and civil society organizations, and relied on churches, unions, student organizations, and volunteers to reach the territories. This plurality of agents helped present the initiative as a mobilization of the entire society, while simultaneously making its political direction less visible.

In the following decades, and especially from the 1990s onwards, the expansion of non-governmental organizations, the so-called third sector, and corporate foundations consolidated other combinations between the State, private initiative, and civil society. Educational and social assistance services began to be carried out by private entities, often with public funds and temporary contracts.
Catini calls the current configuration an “educational-welfare-business system.” The expression draws attention to actions that may meet real and urgent needs, but are carried out by organizations subject to the continuous search for funding. In these cases, the precariousness of employment contracts combines with the instability of the service itself. “An intermittent organization ends up producing an intermittent social right,” he states.
The presence of public power, therefore, does not disappear. The State can continue as a funder, contractor, regulator, or guarantor of a network implemented by private entities. At the same time, foundations linked to large companies begin to formulate materials, methods, indicators, and policies that circulate between non-formal education and school networks.
One of the examples studied by Catini is "youth protagonism." This expression, now widespread in youth programs and educational policies, seems to attribute greater decision-making power to students. Based on research by Regina Magalhães de Souza, the professor traces its relationship to business training technologies, including Odebrecht's Business Technology, which sought to direct young people's willingness to act and transform the world towards entrepreneurship and work. What was presented as autonomy could thus function as a channeling of political energy towards objectives defined by funding organizations.
Conservative training in the territories
It is within this historical context that contemporary initiatives can be examined. The company Brasil Paralelo does not define the Mecenas Project as popular education. It presents it as its “philanthropic initiative,” created to bring content to Brazilians with limited access to information and infrastructure. According to data released by the company itself, the project distributes subscriptions to its platform to more than 23 people in all states and reaches more than 300 institutions, including schools and social entities. The materials cover history, politics, philosophy, arts, psychology, virtues, and “strengthening bonds.”
In November 2024, a report by The Intercept Brazil , based on videos of 17 meetings and reports sent to funders, showed that the program then had 6 patron members and had reached at least 284 institutions. According to the investigation, the meetings presented the project as part of a strategy to confront what the company considered progressive dominance over education and included the purpose of training teachers aligned with its values. Brasil Paralelo did not respond to the questions sent by the publication at that time.
In the project's public presentation, the company states that the content is complementary and optional, and that the program expands access to "safe and quality education." It also reports that, in addition to subscriptions, it has begun funding institutional renovations and scholarships for a History degree. The combination of private donors, a media platform, schools, assistance centers, and socially vulnerable populations makes the Mecenas Project especially relevant to the problem investigated by Catini: the form of the action may resemble social or community education, but its direction remains focused on those who finance and select the content.
A study published in March 2026 by Edson André Pereira Hilário and Amanda Marcia dos Santos Reinaldo analyzed another documentary by the company, *The Hidden Face of Paulo Freire* . Without evaluating whether the criticisms of the educator were true or false, the authors investigated the narrative mechanisms employed to reconstruct him as a cultural threat. The conclusion is that the production transforms pedagogy into a battlefield and Freire's name into a symbol of an antagonism that goes beyond the debate about teaching methods.
Conservative investment in political training also appears outside of schools and social assistance projects. Created in 2021, the MBL Academy claims to prepare candidates, advisors, leaders, intellectuals, and activists for the Free Brazil Movement. On its website, it promises to connect students with regional spokespeople and direct those who excel to campaigns, offices, and party directorates.
A report by Agência Pública followed a group of approximately 430 young people and described a methodology that combines classes, content creation for social media, dossier compilation, group organization, and lobbying of municipal councils. Although the MBL Academy does not claim the name of popular education, its actions demonstrate that militant training, the creation of nuclei, and the struggle for so-called cultural hegemony are no longer identified solely with left-wing organizations.
For Catini, this does not mean that conservative groups have converted to Popular Education. Appropriation occurs when audiences, spaces, mobilization techniques, and words developed in popular processes are preserved, while the possibility for participants to collectively define the purpose of the action is reduced. Emancipation , in this shift, can come to mean individual success or financial independence; participation can be reduced to adherence to a pre-established agenda; autonomy can be translated as entrepreneurship; and community can become merely the territory for the application of an external project.
Who asks the questions?
Other experiences help to make the contrast visible. Throughout 2025, the Grito das Periferias project held workshops with 94 teenagers and young people from Ceilândia, Estrutural, and Itapoã, in the Federal District. The activities addressed human rights, race, gender, the right to the city, culture, and the public budget. Participants produced the communication for the meetings, organized events in their territories, and developed proposals presented at a public hearing in the Legislative Chamber of the Federal District.
The initiative, developed by the Institute of Socioeconomic Studies with local organizations and support from the Secretariat of Justice and Citizenship of the Federal District, claims to adopt popular education as its method. The decisive factor is not only the social profile of the participants or the location of the workshops. The demands were formulated by young people based on the experiences of their territories and compiled into a manifesto addressed to public authorities and candidates in the 2026 elections. Instead of receiving a pre-built solution, they participated in defining the problems and transformed the training into political advocacy.

The example does not offer an automatic classification nor does it eliminate the contradictions of any funded project. However, it shows why the word "protagonism" needs to be confronted with the concrete organization of the activity: do young people choose the themes and can they alter their course, or do they merely carry out tasks conceived by adults, companies, or party leadership?
In the Non-Formal Education course offered by FE-Unicamp, Pedagogy students conduct fieldwork in social movements, non-governmental organizations, cultural institutions, and corporate foundations. Afterwards, these experiences are brought back to the classroom. The comparison between practices as different as those developed by the Landless Rural Workers Movement and by a corporate foundation transforms the very concept into an object of debate.
For Catini, the analysis should not deny the importance that a workshop, a cultural project, or a social assistance action can have on the trajectory of its participants. The point is not to confuse this particular effect with collective emancipation, nor to consider the structure that makes the experience possible as neutral. "Non-formal education has become a laboratory field for the implementation of methodologies," she states. Some of these methodologies subsequently transcend the walls of the school and begin to guide policies for entire networks.
More than deciding which label fits each initiative, the distinction between popular, social, community, and non-formal education thus proposes a roadmap for investigation. Who formulated the problem? Who pays for the project? How are its workers hired? What relationship does it maintain with the State? Can the participants challenge its objectives and transform them? Does the practice strengthen collective organization or adapt individuals to conditions that remain unchanged?
The answers prevent the word "popular" from being reduced to the audience to whom an action is directed. They also show why education has become a strategic territory in contemporary political debate. The question is not only who can reach the communities, but who can speak on their behalf—and whether they themselves participate in the construction of that voice.
Scientific Articles
CATINI, Carolina de Roig. Non-formal education: history and critique of a social form . Education and Research, v. 47, 2021. DOI: 10.1590/S1678-4634202147222980. Access to the text
SCHLINDWEIN, Ian Gabriel Couto; CATINI, Carolina de Roig. Popular education as a collective practice of insurgency and emancipation . Revista Tempos e Espaços em Educação, v. 14, n. 33, 2021. DOI: 10.20952/revtee.v14i33.14279. Access to the text
BRANDÃO, Carlos Rodrigues. Alternative education in an authoritarian society . In: PAIVA, Vanilda (org.). Perspectives and dilemmas of popular education. 2nd ed. Rio de Janeiro: Graal, 1986. p. 171-202.
ANANIAS, Lucas Andrade; RAMOS, Nara Vieira. Contexts of non-formal education based on a literature review (2013–2023) . Revista Teias, v. 27, n. 84, 2026. DOI: 10.12957/teias.2026.85657. Access to the text
HILÁRIO, Edson André Pereira; REINALDO, Amanda Marcia dos Santos. The oppressed pedagogue: an analysis of conservative discourse in the documentary The Hidden Face of Paulo Freire . Revista Espaço Pedagógico, v. 33, 2026. DOI: 10.5335/rep.v33.17452. Access to the text
Reports and documents
AGÊNCIA BRASIL. SP: Protest criticizes use of public school in film against Paulo Freire . April 18, 2026. Access to the text.
PUBLIC AGENCY. Mission Party: the power project of Renan Santos and the MBL . July 31, 2026. Access to the text.
BRAZIL PARALLEL. Get to know the Mecenas Project, the social initiative of Brazil Parallel . December 28, 2024. Access the text.
BRAZIL PARALLEL. Pedagogy of abandonment: BP documentary on early childhood education premieres today . April 20, 2026. Access the text.
FOLHA DE S.PAULO. Families mobilize against Brasil Paralelo documentary filmed in a São Paulo daycare center . April 17, 2026. Access the text.
INESC. The "Grito das Periferias" Project trains young people and brings the demands of the peripheries to the public budget of the Federal District . Updated May 4, 2026. Access the text.
INTERCEPT BRASIL. Brasil Paralelo: program that attracts “patrons” to combat the left has already reached 284 schools and NGOs . November 27, 2024. Access the text.
